9 Car Insurers That Are Actually Affordable

Photo of author
Jonathon Klotz
Published:

It’s a fact of life that unless you live in a major city, you need a car to get anywhere in the country. That means you need car insurance, and as all drivers know, policies can be alarmingly expensive. Thankfully, the team at Value Penguin has put together a list of the cheapest car insurance policies.

Every policy on this list is liability-only, which is to say, the lowest level legally available. These rate estimates depend on your state; for example, if you live in a no-fault state like Florida,  it will be far more expensive. Shopping for insurance can be confusing and time-consuming, so hopefully, this guide will help make things a little easier.

Farmers

Farmers Insurance Group Agent Location. Farmers Provides Home, Life and Car Insurance I
Image Credit: Jonathan Weiss/Shutterstock.

Farmers is an interesting case, as it routinely rates 14% more expensive than the average policy, but there’s a catch: some of the best available customer service and the ability to customize your policy. Farmers will run you around $99 a month for straight, no-frills, liability-only insurance.

AllState

Allstate Insurance exterior and logo. The Allstate Corporation is the second largest personal lines insurer in the United States.
Image Credit: Ken Wolter/Shutterstock.

At $93, AllState is a great option that can be significantly cheaper. With an extensive list of potential discounts, from the SafeDriver discount to Drivewise, you might be able to pay well under the average. The largest advantage AllState has is the size of its agent network so that no matter where you live, there’s going to be an agent nearby.

Amica

Amica Mutual Insurance website homepage. Amica Mutual Insurance logo visible.
Image Credit: Casimiro PT/Shutterstock.

The $91 rate for Amica comes with a catch since that rate will not be possible for a new driver. If you’re an established driver, the sign-up and claims processes through Amica are some of the easiest in the industry. If you have traffic violations, keep looking, but if you have a clean and safe record, Amicia can be an underrated option.

Nationwide

Closeup Nationwide sign at their headquarters in Columbus, Ohio, USA. Nationwide is a group of U.S. insurance and financial services companies.
Image Credit: JHVEPhoto/Shutterstock.

Not only is Nationwide by your side, but so is more of your money, with an $80 average for car insurance. The deeply discounted usage option may not be available in your state, and even if it is, at a 12,000 miles a year limit, that might only work for some lifestyles. It’s worth reaching out to an agent to find out if you fall in the narrow use case that makes Nationwide one of the best options.

Travelers

Travelers office in Hartford, Connecticut, USA, on November 8, 2023. Travelers is an American insurance company.
Image Credit: JHVEPhoto/Shutterstock.

Travelers is known for comprehensive umbrella policies, but if you only need car insurance, it’s still worth looking at this company. At $70, it’s affordable, but the catch is that you need to pay the bill in full every month, and as with all insurance companies, one accident will make the rate significantly higher. If you want coverage options, Travelers can be a good choice, but be aware of the downsides.

Progressive

Progressive insurance office headquarters entrance sign in Tampa, Florida
Image Credit: Kristi Blokhin/Shutterstock.

If you have a motorcycle, Progressive is one of the best options available, even if you have a few traffic violations. At $66, Progressive’s rates, even for drivers with a DUI, are some of the most affordable. As the largest insurance company in the country, options will be available in every state, but by covering motorcycles with custom parts, there’s no better option for bikers.

Geico

GEICO Insurance Office. GEICO is a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway.
Image Credit: Jonathan Weiss/Shutterstock.

Geico might be your best option if you have poor credit or even no credit. $61 for liability-only is a fantastic rate, and even then, upgrading to full coverage averages $258 a month, over 15% under the national average. Geico’s large list of potential discounts, from usage rates to safe drivers, can make it even more affordable for qualified drivers.

American Family

Sign for Local AMERICAN FAMILY INSURANCE Agency beneath Blue Sky
Image Credit: Jon Kraft/Shutterstock.

Suppose American Family is available in your state. In that case, it might be the best option, as the $61 average can be significantly reduced with the largest amount of discounts of any insurance company. Unlike most of the other insurance companies, American Family will offer a discount for safe teen drivers and students, making it the best option for young drivers.

State Farm

State Farm corporate headquarters in Bloomington, Illinois, USA. State Farm Insurance is a large group of mutual insurance companies throughout the USA.
Image Credit: JHVEPhoto/Shutterstock.

A liability-only option through State Farm will run you $50 on average, a rate no other company can compete with, thanks to its status as the largest auto insurance company in the country. The catch is that you have to find a local agent to purchase a policy, but if you live in one of the 18 states that offer the largest discounts, State Farm is, on average, the best option.

 

15 Things That Are No Longer Worth It Because of How Expensive They Have Become

Portrait of beautiful young blonde woman posing and giving a kiss to the camera.
Image Credit: PKpix/Shutterstock.

 

Everything comes with a hefty price tag these days. From indulgences to essentials, the cost of living keeps rising. We used to consider certain items affordable options, but now they’ve become so expensive that they’re no longer worth it. Here are 15 things that have lost their affordability and make us wonder if they are worth it!

15 Things That Are No Longer Worth It Because of How Expensive They Have Become

28 Practical Ways Frugal People Save Lots of Money

Young pretty woman traveller in baseball cap looks and smiles at camera at green nature forest background, portrait close up.
Image Credit: DedMityay/Shutterstock.

 

Saving money doesn’t have to mean saying goodbye to life’s little indulgences. With a few smart tweaks, you can stash away cash for that dream vacation, rainy day fund, or splurge-worthy purchase without feeling like you’re on a constant budget patrol.

Think of it as a side hustle that pays off without the extra hours. Whether you’re looking to conquer debt or simply boost your bank account, these tips are guaranteed to put more money in your pocket, painlessly.

28 Practical Ways Frugal People Save Lots of Money

15 Ways Frugal People Save Money on Their Grocery Bill

Smiling woman buying packed salad while shopping at grocery store.
Image Credit: Drazen Zigic/Shutterstock.

 

High grocery prices don’t seem to be going anywhere, so it’s crucial to find ways to cut costs to help keep food costs low. Here are fifteen examples of money-saving things you can do to spend less at the grocery store.

15 Ways Frugal People Save Money on Their Grocery Bill

Author: Jonathan Klotz

Bio:

Jonathan is a veteran librarian with over 16 years of experience in both academic and public libraries. Now, he’s a full-time writer, contributing to some of the most popular websites on the internet.

 

He also runs Positive Nerdery.